Russian Death-Tanks

Numerous YouTube videos depict the widespread destruction of Russian tanks in the invasion of Ukraine, giving the impression that these tanks are more lethal to Russian soldiers than their opponents. Despite being equipped with Explosive Reactive Armor (ERA), their ability to withstand artillery, mines, and drone attacks seems minimal. Moreover, when the armor is breached, the cannon gun propellant tends to ignite violently, causing the warheads to explode and instantly killing the crew. Occasionally, the force of ammunition blasts is so strong that it hurls the turret with gun barrel into the air, a stark illustration of the power of such explosions. Consequently, videos frequently capture Russian tank crews abandoning their crippled vehicles and fleeing for safety. Instead of offering protection, tanks have become conspicuous and cumbersome targets, prone to devastating attacks.

One might question the practical value of reactive armor. The landscapes of eastern Ukraine are strewn with thousands of destroyed Russian tanks, their ERA blocks still intact. Perhaps its practical value lies in bolstering the confidence of tank crews to engage in battle, trusting in the ERA’s protective capabilities. However, it is now challenging to believe that ERA instills a sense of safety in tank crew members. The effectiveness of reactive armor seems negated by potent penetrator warhead countermeasures capable of breaching the ERA. The pertinent question remains: does the ERA diminish the impact of an incoming shell sufficiently to be considered effective?

The conflict between Putin and Ukraine will eventually conclude, and the victors will promptly seek to repurpose the battlefields for peacetime activities. However, they must first contend with numerous challenges, including the presence of unexploded ordnance. Thousands of mines may remain hidden, posing a threat for decades unless they are securely disposed of or neutralized.

The landscape of the battle zones is marred by bomb craters, charred vehicles—many with unexploded ammunition—minefields, unexploded ordnance scattered about, live explosive reactive armor on destroyed armored vehicles, and soil polluted with shrapnel and residues from countless detonated artillery shells.

Numerous cities and villages, particularly those near the Russian border, have been completely obliterated by Putin’s military, resulting in tens of thousands of civilian casualties and leaving most without homes. The remnants of homes, businesses, and infrastructure stand as a testament to the survivors. For them, social and economic frameworks are now just distant memories. Civilization has been set back by at least a generation due to Putin’s distorted ambitions for an imperial legacy. The man is not insane or unintelligent; he is quite astute and fully aware of his actions—he is simply a terrible person. Currently, the US is facing its own challenge with a figure of ill repute seeking control of the government, backed by a significant number of misguided followers.

The conflict has been a catastrophic event for the region’s flora and fauna, significantly hindering the biosphere in numerous areas. Ukraine, until recently, was a significant grain producer and exporter, essential for the sustenance of millions. In the early stages of the conflict, Russia targeted and destroyed much of Ukraine’s grain distribution infrastructure, aiming to debilitate the economy and hasten a surrender. The bombings of civilian residences, hospitals, and other infrastructures will tarnish Putin’s reputation, marking him as a tyrant and a fundamentally flawed individual. Additionally, the reported abduction of thousands of Ukrainian children by Russia for forced assimilation and adoption raises serious legal and humanitarian questions. These actions are meticulously recorded for potential future war crimes proceedings and historical record.

2 thoughts on “Russian Death-Tanks

  1. Ellie Kesselman

    Dear Gaussling,
    I hope this finds you well and in relatively good spirits. You write so nicely, regardless of subject matter. I hope you realize that! As for Putin and Donald Trump, I infer that our stances are different.

    On Twitter, we sometimes discuss what the most exotic coordinates in a set space of support defined such that x = {Russia, Ukraine} and y = {Gaza/Hamas, Israel}. I am one of the rare {x, y} = Russia, Israel points.
    I am all the more peculiar given that my demographic profile is American, female, and Jewish although conservative (but not necessarily GOP!) and STEM-y. You are definitely in the x = Ukraine sub-set! Regardless, I have a few non-hostile thoughts after reading your blog post.
    * First, my heart is comforted by the profound compassion you have for Russian soldiers killed in this unnecessary war. You don’t refer to them as “orcs”. Thank you.
    * Please know that I don’t support Putin. I do notice that many ex-pat and currently Russia-residing Russians–who are highly-educated, intelligent, well-informed, and aren’t rabid nationalists–are unperturbed by Putin being a dictator. I have given up on trying to understand that!
    * As for Donald Trump, I found this data visualization, published by Bloomberg a few years ago, informative https://x.com/EllieAsksWhy/status/1438020826146611200 I’m still trying to relocate the original as the image isn’t clear and requires trusting my annotated version!

    I’m curious about the seeming ineffectiveness of Explosive Reactive Armor that you described! I’ll ask around for a plausible explanation. I’ll try to filter out armchair generals and partisans of all sorts.

    Reply
    1. gaussling Post author

      Hi Ellie,

      Thank you for taking time to pass along the kind words. I really do appreciate it.

      I had the good fortune to work alongside several Soviet scientists just before the USSR collapsed in the very early 1990’s. We sat and watched Gulf War 1 on CNN together and saw, to their dismay, their Skud missiles Soviet tanks fail miserably for Saddam. They were indeed dismayed in a patriotic way but also not surprised at all. The Russian woman told stories about her days doing target practice in the Young Pioneers taking practice shots at the American guys. We laughed about it.

      I visited Russia in 2000 in an attempt to do business with potential chemical suppliers there. I visited a few homes and a chemical plant. I was treated with respect and received many kind gestures.

      I have a soft spot for the Russian people, their culture and their difficult history.

      I have to believe that one day the Russian people will resist autocrats like Putin and establish a more agreeable form of government.

      Cheers!

      Reply

Leave a reply to gaussling Cancel reply