Tag Archives: Antony Beevor

WTF’s Wrong With Russia?

Many have been trying to understand what’s the problem with Putin’s Russia as a political entity and as culture. Why was the Soviet Union so refractory to the idea of peaceful coexistence with the west? Their posture was that the west was aggressively hostile and an immediate threat to the USSR. The west in the form of NATO always responded in kind in the measure-countermeasure cold war seesaw until the Soviet Union eventually collapsed from economic exhaustion. The Soviet Union collapsed but KGB officer Vladimir Putin did not.

Thatcher Anecdote

In fairness it must be said that NATO, under strong urging by the USA, suffered from a similar mania in reaction to the threat of communist domination and acted accordingly until the collapse of the USSR. I attended a talk given by Maggie Thatcher in 1992 wherein she boasted about how she and Ronald Reagan brought about the collapse of the Soviet Union. Recently I took an online class on the political history of eastern Europe from the early interwar period to the Soviet collapse. Fascinating class. In class I had the opportunity to ask a half-serious question to the recitation professor about this Thatcher-Reagan business and when the snickering died down was politely told that Thatcher’s assertion was not accurate. Imagine that.

Sir Antony Beevor

Several interviews on YouTube by Russian scholars and writers have appeared recently that seem to have cogent views. First is historian Sir Antony Beevor who has appeared in many interviews popping up from the algorithm lately. His specialties are the history of the Bolshevik revolution, the Russian civil war and WWII. In a recent interview Beevor quipped that Putin was “a Soviet man’. Putin has lamented many times about the tragedy of collapse of the USSR. Putin’s military operation stumbles forward with the added complexity of amassing military forces along borders to NATO countries.

Back in the USSR

Many believe that Putin is obviously trying to rebuild the Soviet Union by annexation by force. Poland is acutely aware of this. There is an English language broadcast on YouTube from TVP, a public station in Poland that refutes Russian propaganda and shows scenes of Russia’s “successes”. You can tell by the tenor of the show that the writers hold Russia in very low esteem. Poland has a terrible history of murderous occupation by the Red Army. As the red Army pushed the Nazis west out of Poland at the end of WWII, the survivors believed that the Soviet Red Army couldn’t be any worse than the Germans. They were quite wrong about the Red Army and Poland still vividly remembers.

Elvira Bary

Russian-American Elvira Bary writes novels and produces YouTube content with her insights on Russian culture. Being an accomplished novelist she has a developed instinct for the subtleties of human nature and a well developed grasp of her own culture. Just listen to how articulately she uses language. It’s very impressive. On a recent video she said don’t ask a Russian if they believe in a particular thing, ask instead what does the belief protect them from. With a very long history of oppressive authoritarian rule with food shortages, Russians are masters of the work-around to get what they want and to get things done. This view of oppressive authority as something to wriggle around with bribes permeates the culture. Bribery was normalized many years ago. Unfair? Illegal? Unethical? It depends If you lower the ethics baseline or not. Think of it as a a tip for good service.

Timothy Snyder

Historian Timothy Snyder, now at the University of Toronto, is a historian of central and eastern Europe and the Soviet Union. He was a frequent interviewee and subject matter expert following Putin’s 2022 invasion of Ukraine. His book Bloodlands: Europe Between Hitler and Stalin described the Holodomor in detail and created a great deal of buzz among historians. The antipathy of Ukrainians towards Russians over this horrific period comes into focus.